The BMW was left in the driveway of a High Ridge Road homeowner, who reported the driver getting into the Range Rover with three other occupants that sped off around 6 a.m., Lt. Christopher Hawken said.
A wallet was taken from another vehicle on High Ridge that was burglarized, he said.
As officers responded, a call came in to police headquarters from a Surrey Lane resident that the stolen Range Rover was hers.
The 2011 BMW, with a Pennsylvania license plate and body damage, turned out to be stolen out of Newark on Monday, responders said.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Jersey City and receive free news updates.